top of page

J4S3 – Blog 6: New Zealand history and New Zealand values: The Hardship Generation, 1900–1945

Writer: Kerry Paul
Kerry Paul
15 hours ago
8 min read

New Zealand Soldiers on a rocky hillside overlook a bay crowded with landing ships, evoking a tense wartime amphibious assault in Gallipoli.
ANZAC Troops Arriving in Gallipoli 25 April 1915

The struggle for security

This article explores how economic hardship and war shaped the values passed between generations, particularly the desire for security and the importance of family responsibility.

New Zealand history and New Zealand values: The Hardship Generation, 1900–1945


This generation represents the struggle for security


This is the period that most directly explains my parents’ habits. My father was born in 1914 and my mother in 1929. War and depression formed part of the world in which they grew up.


The opportunity sought by nineteenth-century migrants did not guarantee lasting security. Their descendants still valued independence and work, but new events tested those assumptions.


In my parents’ generation, the practical lessons of scarcity entered the household and remained there. War, depression, rationing and uncertainty reinforced habits that I later watched in daily life.


The First World War transformed New Zealand's emerging national identity.


From a population of approximately 1.1 million in 1914, around 100,000 New Zealanders served overseas. More than 18,000 died as a result of the war, and over 40,000 were wounded. The scale of the losses was extraordinary for a small country. Families lost sons, fathers, brothers and husbands. Those who returned often carried physical injuries and psychological trauma that affected them for the remainder of their lives.


Women assumed additional responsibilities in households, farms, businesses and voluntary organisations. Families and communities had to adapt to the absence of men who had previously been important contributors to their economic security.


The war reinforced the importance of endurance, loyalty and mutual support. It also encouraged a growing awareness that New Zealanders possessed an identity distinct from that of Britain. The shared experiences of soldiers overseas, particularly at Gallipoli and on the Western Front, contributed to this developing national consciousness.


However, the war also created divisions. Not everyone supported conscription or participation in the conflict, and the experiences of conscientious objectors and different communities were not identical. The emerging national identity was shaped as much by grief and disagreement as by the celebration of military service.

The Great Depression and the meaning of thrift


When I watched my parents save and reuse things, I was seeing habits connected to the insecurity that families had lived through in the 1930s. New Zealand depended heavily on agricultural exports. When international commodity prices collapsed, the consequences spread through farms, businesses and households.


By 1933, export prices had fallen approximately 45% from their 1930 levels, and registered unemployment reached 12% of the workforce. Many people who retained employment experienced substantial wage reductions.


For lower-income families, the Depression was not simply an economic downturn. It was a prolonged struggle to maintain food, shelter and financial security. Those who had previously enjoyed a reasonable standard of living could suddenly find themselves without reliable employment.


For households living through this period, I see thrift as a practical response to hardship rather than a slogan about virtue.


The First World War brought death and injury into communities throughout New Zealand. The Great Depression then produced unemployment, falling incomes and economic insecurity. Just as families began recovering, another world war arrived.


Scarcity shaped expectations. In my childhood home, the money was planned before it was spent.


During the Second World War, petrol, sugar, tea, butter, meat and other commodities were rationed. At one stage private motorists could obtain only about nine litres of petrol a month. Families learned to make do with less, repair rather than replace, preserve food and avoid unnecessary expenditure.


I came to understand thrift as a way of protecting the family against the next setback.


My mother knitted and sewed clothes; garments went to younger siblings or cousins. We used second-hand shoes, clothes and appliances when useful. Tin cans became storage containers, plastic bags were washed and dried on the line, and cardboard was cut into pieces for notes and job lists. These were ordinary household practices, not a programme labelled sustainability.


These practices were not unique to New Zealand, nor did every family experience hardship equally. But for those affected by the Depression, they were practical responses to severe economic insecurity.


As a child, I learned the value of a possession from the care my parents gave it. Clothing was washed, dried outdoors, kept and passed on. A dryer, where available, was used sparingly.


I absorbed a simple rule: save before buying. Without the money, we waited, found a second-hand option or went without. Credit cards were not part of our household. I now see that thrift was both a habit and a form of protection against uncertainty.


I also see a stronger demand for collective security in the response to the Depression. Hardworking people could lose their employment through circumstances entirely beyond their control. Personal effort and thrift were not always sufficient to protect a family. This experience contributed to public support for greater economic security and the expansion of social welfare during the 1930s.


New Zealand's developing identity increasingly combined the expectation that individuals should make their own efforts with the belief that society should provide protection against severe hardship.

Men dig a deep roadside trench by hand, one in a hooded coat and another in a cap, with shovels in a muddy black-and-white scene.
Public Works During Great Depression Drainage Gang in New Zealand

The Second World War: Another generation of sacrifice


The outbreak of the Second World War in 1939 confronted families with another period of uncertainty before many had fully recovered from the Depression.


Approximately 140,000 New Zealand men and women served overseas, and almost 12,000 New Zealand military personnel lost their lives. The conflict required an extensive mobilisation of people, industry and national resources.


For families at home, the war meant separation, anxiety, shortages and restrictions on consumption. Food, clothing and other resources had to be managed carefully. Women undertook additional work in industry, agriculture, administration and community organisations.


The habits of thrift developed during the Depression became valuable again. Families learned to make do with what they possessed, maintain essential equipment and place collective needs ahead of some personal preferences. The experience reinforced the importance of planning, saving and avoiding waste. It also demonstrated that national survival depended on coordinated effort as well as individual determination.


For many families, the two world wars and the Great Depression formed a continuous period of disruption rather than three isolated historical events.


A child born in 1900 could have experienced the First World War as a teenager, the Depression in their thirties and the Second World War in their forties. By 1945, that person had spent much of their adult life living through extraordinary uncertainty.

Black-and-white factory floor with rows of workers assembling machinery under steel beams; sign reads LIGHTS SERVICE DEPT.
World War Two Effort Women at Work  


What my parents passed to me


For me, the longest legacy of war and depression was the pattern of behaviour children learned at home. The nineteenth-century migrant generation had sought independence and opportunity. Their descendants learned that even a prosperous society could be disrupted by war, unemployment and economic collapse.


Together, these experiences helped establish a set of values that influenced many New Zealand households well into the second half of the twentieth century.


Inherited value

How it influenced everyday life

Self-reliance

Taking responsibility for oneself and one's family.

Thrift

Saving money, avoiding waste and repairing possessions.

Resourcefulness

Finding practical solutions without relying on expensive resources.

Hard work

Viewing sustained effort as a means of improving family circumstances.

Resilience

Accepting setbacks and adapting to changing circumstances.

Community responsibility

Helping neighbours and supporting people facing hardship.

Independence

Valuing personal initiative and opportunities for advancement.


I learned these values by watching, not from a formal family statement. I watched a strict household budget, simple meals and a predictable weekly plan that made shopping efficient. The annual holiday was usually to a nearby beach; overseas travel was not part of our expectations.


My parents also taught me, by example, to think of family as a source of care. We spent time with older relatives and helped them with practical tasks. Food was traded among family, friends and neighbours without every favour becoming a financial transaction.


For some, the experience of hardship encouraged caution and an aversion to debt. For others, it encouraged entrepreneurship and a determination to escape the insecurity their parents had experienced.


The same historical circumstances could therefore produce different responses. One person might seek the security of permanent employment, while another might establish a business to gain greater control over their future. Both responses could reflect the same underlying desire for independence and financial security.

The settler ideal and its limits


By the middle of the twentieth century, several generations of New Zealanders had experienced a remarkable sequence of events. Their ancestors had travelled across the world seeking opportunities unavailable to them in Britain or Europe. They had established homes, farms, businesses and communities under difficult circumstances. Their descendants had then experienced two world wars and the Great Depression.


I recognise the practical, independent and economical person described in this settler ideal because I saw those qualities in my parents.


Yet this was never the complete national identity. Māori traditions, the experiences of other immigrant communities, urbanisation and changing social attitudes all contributed to the country's development. The idea of the rugged, self-reliant pioneer was also partly a cultural ideal rather than an accurate description of every New Zealander.


The distinctive feature of the emerging settler identity was arguably the combination of two aspirations: the desire for personal independence and the expectation of a society offering ordinary people a reasonable opportunity to improve their lives. The first encouraged initiative and self-reliance. The second encouraged cooperation and the development of institutions intended to provide greater economic security.


These aspirations were sometimes in tension, but both became influential features of New Zealand's social and economic culture.

What the migrant and hardship years mean to me


The British and other European migrants who arrived in New Zealand during the nineteenth century were not simply seeking a change of scenery. Many were seeking to escape the economic and social limitations that had constrained their families for generations.


Their decision required courage, ambition and a willingness to accept considerable uncertainty. Establishing themselves in New Zealand demanded adaptability, practical skills, perseverance and cooperation.


The generations that followed faced challenges of a different magnitude. Two world wars brought immense personal loss, while the Great Depression demonstrated how quickly financial security could disappear.


For many New Zealand families, these experiences reinforced the importance of thrift, resourcefulness, hard work and responsibility for future generations. The result was a cultural inheritance in which independence and community responsibility existed alongside one another.


The migrants sought the freedom to build a better life. Their descendants learned how important it was to protect what they had built. Together, these experiences helped shape many of the values that New Zealanders came to associate with their national character.


The lesson I inherited was that a better future required initiative, care with resources and help from others. I also learned that effort alone could not prevent war, unemployment or hardship.


Out of these experiences emerged a recognisable New Zealand cultural ideal: practical rather than theoretical, suspicious of excessive status, economical with resources, willing to improvise, prepared to work physically, and reluctant to make too much fuss about adversity.


Of course, this was never the experience of every New Zealander. Māori histories were very different, particularly because European settlement was accompanied by warfare, land alienation and profound economic and cultural disruption. Nor were British settlers one homogeneous group. English, Scottish, Irish and Welsh migrants arrived from different social and religious backgrounds.


In many families, including my own, an enduring message took shape: Take responsibility for what you can, save when you are able and help the people who depend on you.

Why this matters to my inquiry


I did not arrive independently at every belief I hold. I learned much of my outlook from repeated practices within a household shaped by earlier events.


For many nineteenth-century British and European migrants, coming to New Zealand represented a decision to exchange the limitations of the society they knew for the risks of an uncertain future. They crossed the world because they believed they could create something better.


Their descendants then encountered war, depression and scarcity. Those experiences reinforced thrift, resilience, practicality and self-reliance. The history helps me understand why the values of thrift, independence and mutual help could sit together in one family.


It was not simply the isolation of New Zealand that shaped the national character. It was the type of people prepared to make the journey, the challenges they encountered after arriving, and the hardships subsequently experienced by their children and grandchildren.


In that sense, migration did more than populate nineteenth-century New Zealand: It helped select and reinforce the attitudes that would influence New Zealand society for generations.


I next ask what happened when children raised with those habits encountered the greater opportunities of the postwar decades.

To continue reading Journey 4 – Series 3 Click Here: J4S3 – Blog 7: The Postwar Generation, 1945–2000

Comments


bottom of page