top of page

J4S3 – Blog 15: New Zealand society; New Zealand values: The National Character We Need to Confront

Writer: Kerry Paul
Kerry Paul
15 hours ago
9 min read

Scales balance FAIRNESS and PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY beside a sign listing challenges ahead at sunset over mountains and city.
Examples of New Zealand Values

Fairness, personal responsibility and the challenges facing New Zealand

Having explored the characteristics New Zealanders like to associate with themselves, this article turns the argument around and asks where reality falls short of those ideals.

New Zealand society; New Zealand values: The National Character We Need to Confront

As I have worked through The Making of the New Zealand Character, I have concentrated largely on the qualities that New Zealanders have traditionally admired in themselves: fairness, egalitarianism, independence, modesty, practicality, resilience, informality, friendliness and the belief that everyone deserves a fair go.

But national character cannot be understood simply by celebrating our strengths. I also have to ask a more uncomfortable question: have some aspects of our character, and some changes in our society, begun to work against the kind of country we believe New Zealand should be?

There are aspects of our character that are provocative however any examination must include them in our discussion. In particular, parenting, education, welfare and prisons, together with a growing culture of entitlement affecting both Māori and Pākehā are topical issues. We should have a conversation about New Zealand’s most difficult social problems.

In this Blog we are prepared to ask questions many people would rather avoid.

From self-reliance to entitlement

One of the strongest concerns is what is regarded as a growing culture of entitlement.

The New Zealand character that developed through earlier generations placed considerable emphasis on personal responsibility. Whether Māori communities, nineteenth-century settlers, farmers, tradespeople or working families, survival usually depended upon contributing to the family and community. People certainly helped one another, but there was also an expectation that those capable of contributing should do so.

Is this something that has changed?


A civilised society clearly has a responsibility to support people who cannot support themselves. The concern is whether long-term dependency where people who could potentially become independent instead become trapped within a system that unintentionally removes the incentive to change.


That distinction is important to me.


The fair go was never intended to mean that everyone should receive the same outcome regardless of effort. It meant that people should be given a reasonable opportunity to make something of their lives.

If entitlement replaces opportunity as the dominant expectation, we risk changing something fundamental in the New Zealand character.



Opportunity backpacker at signposts for Business, Career, Skills, Travel, Start-up; Entitlement: sad man gets a handout.
Opportunity versus Entitlement. We have choices


Personal responsibility cannot disappear


This leads to what I see as the central question: where does society's responsibility end and personal responsibility begin?


There is an understandable tendency to explain social failure through external circumstances—poverty, colonisation, racism, unemployment, inadequate housing, inequality and failures of government policy. These factors can be real and powerful.


One argument is that by concentrating exclusively on external causes can unintentionally remove individual agency. The argument is that while we need to understand why people find themselves in difficult circumstances, those circumstances should not be used to excuse destructive behaviour or remove personal responsibility for changing it.


This is particularly apparent in the widespread discussion of the social world depicted in Once Were Warriors. This is not typical of the Māori way of life. The majority of Māori work, raise families and participate constructively in society. The concern is a smaller dysfunctional underclass in which unemployment, alcohol or drugs, violence and intergenerational disadvantage can reinforce one another.


That qualification matters. Social dysfunction should never be confused with ethnicity.


The national-character question is much broader: are we becoming reluctant to hold individuals responsible for behaviour because we are increasingly inclined to explain that behaviour through circumstances?


A mature society should be capable of doing both. We can understand the circumstances that produced someone's behaviour while still expecting them to take responsibility for changing it.

The family is where national character begins


Parenting, I think this deserves serious attention when discussing national character.


Governments can build schools, fund health services, provide housing assistance and create welfare programmes. But they cannot completely replace parents.


Character begins long before a child understands politics or national identity.


Children learn whether education matters. They learn whether promises should be kept. They learn how adults resolve disagreements. They learn whether violence is acceptable. They learn whether work is worthwhile. They learn how men treat women and how adults treat children.


Most importantly, they learn what is normal.


Literacy can fundamentally change children's opportunities. Children arriving at school without having been read to is controversial when generalised culturally, but the underlying point is powerful: disadvantages established before school can become increasingly difficult to overcome afterwards.


I therefore think strengthening the New Zealand character has to begin within families.

We spend enormous amounts attempting to repair problems later in life that may have originated during the first few years.

Education must restore opportunity


Education is closely connected to this. One of the great historical aspirations of New Zealand was that a person's background should not determine their future. Education was supposed to provide the ladder.


For me, that remains one of the most important expressions of the fair go.


But a fair education system cannot simply provide access to a classroom. It must produce literacy, numeracy, knowledge, discipline, curiosity and the confidence to participate in society.


The role of books is especially important. Reading does more than provide an academic skill. It opens other worlds. It exposes children to possibilities beyond their immediate circumstances.


That is why the question should not simply be whether children attend school. It should be: are we equipping every child to become an independent adult capable of participating fully in New Zealand society? If large numbers leave school without those capabilities, the consequences eventually appear elsewhere—in welfare dependency, unemployment, poor health, crime and imprisonment.


Education therefore does much more than produce workers. It transmits national character from one generation to the next. We cannot accept intergenerational dysfunction as inevitable


One of New Zealand’s most disturbing themes is the transmission of dysfunction between generations. Violence provides a particularly powerful example. This distinction matters because problems that are learned can potentially be unlearned.


Children raised around violence can come to regard violence as normal. Children raised where nobody works may have fewer examples of employment as a normal adult responsibility. Children surrounded by alcohol and drugs may regard substance abuse differently from children growing up without it.


The greatest danger is when society begins treating such outcomes as inevitable. This distinction matters because problems that are learned can potentially be unlearned.

Breaking these cycles should be one of New Zealand's highest priorities because every generation that escapes them changes the prospects of the generation following it.

Prison represents failure long before the crime


New Zealand's prison population represents one of the clearest signs of deeper social problems, particularly when imprisonment becomes the end result of intergenerational cycle, family dysfunction, poor educational achievement, addiction, violence and a failure to intervene effectively before offending becomes entrenched.


It is easy to view imprisonment simply as punishment for an offence. But by the time somebody reaches prison, numerous earlier institutions may already have failed: family, school, community, welfare, health services and sometimes previous interventions by the justice system.


Releasing from custody somebody without accommodation, employment or sufficient resources to establish themselves makes successful reintegration considerably harder.


This appeals to the pragmatic side of the traditional Kiwi character.


If we genuinely want fewer prisoners, we have to ask what happens before prison and after prison, rather than simply debating punishment.


Accountability remains essential. But rehabilitation is also practical self-interest. A former prisoner who becomes employed, supports a family and contributes to society is a far better outcome than someone cycling repeatedly through the justice system.


The fair go must involve obligations as well as rights. This brings me back to a concept that runs throughout my examination of New Zealand character—the fair go. We usually describe the fair go in terms of rights. Everyone deserves opportunity. Everyone should be treated fairly. Background should not permanently determine destiny.


But I increasingly believe we have neglected the other half of the equation. A functioning society also depends upon obligations.


Parents have obligations to children. Citizens have obligations to one another. Those who can work have some obligation to contribute. Governments have an obligation to create genuine opportunities. Schools have an obligation to educate. Individuals have an obligation to take reasonable responsibility for their decisions.


Rights without responsibilities eventually become entitlement. Responsibilities without rights become oppression. The New Zealand fair go historically worked because, at its best, it attempted to balance the two. We need to recover our willingness to disagree

Our ability to have difficult conversations


There is another issue that I think has become increasingly important: our ability to have difficult conversations. Political correctness can shut down discussion by making people afraid to express views that conflict with accepted thinking.


That, to me, is the larger national-character issue.


New Zealand has traditionally valued plain speaking. We have also valued tolerance. We need both. Tolerance should mean accepting another person's right to disagree with me—not requiring that person to agree with me.


A confident society should be capable of discussing colonisation, Māori disadvantage, immigration, welfare, crime, inequality, gender, cultural change and national identity without automatically dividing people into opposing camps.


We should be able to say: I disagree with you. Tell me why you think that.


That is a healthier response than attempting to prevent the conversation.

We must distinguish Māori identity from Māori disadvantage


Māori identity should never become synonymous with social disadvantage. Dysfunctional communities only represent only a minority and that most Māori live ordinary productive lives. This distinction is essential.


Māori culture, language, whakapapa and values are increasingly central to New Zealand's broader national identity. At the same time, disproportionate Māori representation in negative social statistics remains a serious issue.


We should be capable of celebrating the growing importance of Māori identity and culture while also confronting the issue of communities experiencing social and economic disadvantage. These problems must be addressed directly. Because serious social problems rarely have a single cause, solutions require a broad, coordinated approach involving families, communities, education, government and individuals, based on need and circumstances rather than ethnicity alone.


Inequality threatens the egalitarian story


New Zealand's national character has long rested upon the belief that we are relatively egalitarian. That belief matters even when reality has never perfectly matched it. If differences in wealth, housing security and educational opportunity become so great that children grow up in fundamentally different New Zealand’s, the cultural consequences will eventually be significant.


The danger is not simply economic inequality. It is the loss of shared experience.


A society develops national character partly because people from different backgrounds encounter one another—at school, at work, on sports fields, in communities and through public institutions.


When groups become increasingly separated economically, geographically or culturally, maintaining a common national identity becomes harder. The “fair go” therefore cannot simply be remembered nostalgically. It has to remain credible.

Diversity requires something that holds us together


New Zealand is also becoming substantially more diverse. That is changing what it means to be a New Zealander.


The traditional national character was disproportionately shaped by Māori and British-derived Pākehā experiences. Contemporary New Zealand includes increasingly significant Pacific, Asian and other migrant communities.


I see that diversity as potentially enriching our national character. But diversity alone does not create social cohesion. A country also needs common ground.


New Zealanders do not need identical ancestry, religions, cultures or political beliefs. But we do need sufficient agreement about certain underlying principles: democracy, equality before the law, freedom of expression, tolerance, personal responsibility, respect for others and equality of opportunity.


The future Kiwi identity may therefore become less about where our ancestors came from and more about the values we agree to share once we are here.

The danger of complacency


Perhaps the biggest threat to the New Zealand character is complacency. We like the story we tell ourselves: We are friendly, egalitarian, practical, tolerant, giving everyone a fair go and look after one another.


Much of that remains true. But national myths become dangerous when we stop testing them against reality. We need to have insistence that problems should be confronted rather than hidden behind a comfortable national story.


That attitude itself seems remarkably Kiwi to me. The character I believe New Zealand needs. We do not need to abandon our traditional national character but renew it.


We need:

1. the fair go, but it must combine opportunity with responsibility.

2. compassion, but compassion should help people become independent wherever that is realistically possible.

3. welfare, but we should not allow long-term avoidable dependency to become an accepted way of life.

4. stronger families because governments cannot successfully replace parents.

5. education that gives every child genuine command of literacy and numeracy and therefore a realistic chance of independence.

6. to confront violence, addiction and intergenerational dysfunction without confusing social problems with ethnicity.

7. tolerance—but tolerance must include people whose opinions we dislike.


And we need a renewed understanding that citizenship involves responsibilities as well as rights.


We should understand the historical context where our character came from and what New Zealanders are like.


The more important question for the next generation is:


What kind of national character do we want to preserve—and what behaviours are we prepared to change to preserve it?


New Zealand's character was never fixed. Each generation inherited values from those before it, modified them to meet new circumstances and passed something different to the generation that followed.


Our responsibility is to decide what is worth carrying forward: fairness without entitlement, compassion with responsibility, diversity with common values, confidence without arrogance, freedom with accountability, and above all the belief that every New Zealander should have both the opportunity—and the responsibility—to make something of that opportunity.


Comments


bottom of page